The Fallout Files

Finalized at 1:30 a.m., approved the same day: the SB Energy term sheet, tested claim by claim against the record

Advertisement

WAVERLY, Ohio — The Pike County Board of Commissioners voted Wednesday, Nov. 18, to approve a non-binding term sheet with SB Energy for an artificial-intelligence data center campus at the PORTS-Pike Technology Campus. The document they approved had been finalized at 1:30 that morning. By the presiding commissioner’s own account, the meeting at which they voted was the first time the full term sheet had ever been presented to the commissioners as a board.

No definitive agreement has been signed. No money moves under what the board approved — the county’s own outside counsel said so on the record, in the same meeting: “There won’t be any money until we sign the definitive agreement. And that won’t be today.”

Advertisement
Advertisement
CapCut

The meeting was recorded in full by Pike County resident Pam Cutler Ison and posted to her Facebook page. J News Network reviewed the entire 76-minute recording. What follows takes each major claim made from the commissioners’ table — the “largest community benefit package in the country,” the cancer answer, the foundation, the jobs, the timeline — and sets it against the documented record, including J News Network’s own previous reporting on this project. The commissioners’ words are printed verbatim. So are the facts.

Officials break ground at the PORTS-Pike site in Piketon, Ohio, March 20, 2026

The claim: “so we can be absolutely transparent”

The commissioner presiding over the meeting opened with a pledge: the session was the board’s “first chance to have something that hopefully has got all the information you guys want,” presented “to the public, to Pike County, so we can be absolutely transparent.”

Advertisement
Southwest Airlines Rapid Rewards
Watch: the presiding commissioner opens the meeting with the board’s pledge — “so we can be absolutely transparent.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

He returned to the point after John Oberly of Ice Miller, the county’s outside counsel, finished presenting the term sheet. The document the board was about to approve, he told the room, had been in the commissioners’ hands no longer than it had been in anyone else’s.

Advertisement

“Just so everybody knows, this is the first time that this whole term sheet has been presented to the commissioners as well,” he said. “We went through parts of it, but it was finalized at 1:30 in the morning last night. So this is the first time — this is not that we’ve had this for two or three weeks and just now getting it out. So we’re happy to give this to everybody. We definitely want to be transparent.”

Watch: the presiding commissioner tells the room the term sheet was “finalized at 1:30 in the morning last night” and that this meeting was the first time the full document had been presented to the board. (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)
The commissioners at the table as the term sheet is presented

The record: A document finalized at 1:30 a.m. and presented to the full board for the first time at the meeting where it was approved is one the public never had the chance to read, and the board itself had seen only in parts. The term sheet’s text was not published with the county’s news release, and residents at the meeting objected that the special meeting was held midday and that notice, they said, appeared only the evening before. Overly responded that notice was posted Monday, that state law requires 24 hours, that the county had issued press releases weeks earlier saying the project would be discussed at every commissioners meeting, and that a postcard about the project was mailed to every house in the county. “Today is the beginning of more comment,” he said, “the beginning of the process.” The process, by then, had a vote at the end of it.

The claim: “the largest community benefit package in the country”

The presiding commissioner endorsed the package in terms the board will now be measured against.

“As of now, we haven’t found a bigger or better community benefit package in the nation than what we have in front of us,” he said. “This has the potential of a full build-out — a potential minimum of $3.6 or $4 billion package for Pike County. Those are astronomical numbers. But as we told SB Energy, everyone came here with big numbers. And one thing we made clear from the very beginning: if you’re going to come here and you’re going to build the largest project in the country, then we’re also going to have the largest community benefit package in the country. I think we’ve been able to do that.”

Watch: the presiding commissioner calls it the largest community benefit package in the nation — “a potential minimum of $3.6 or $4 billion package for Pike County.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

The record: The county’s own numbers do not agree with each other. In a news release issued the same day, the county described the terms as a proposed framework under review and estimated the project could generate $3.3 billion in revenue for the county over 15 years — a different figure from the “$3.6 or $4 billion” minimum described from the table. Both numbers are projections attached to a non-binding document. Neither is money.

Pike County has heard the big-number treatment before. The largest figure attached to this project — $105 billion — is not an investment, a payment or a commitment to spend anything in Pike County. As J News Network reported on Nov. 18, it is the maximum Nvidia could ever owe under residual value guarantees it signed with SB Energy — a cap that pays out only if OpenAI becomes insolvent and defaults, or fails to pay, and then only the shortfall. Nvidia states it has made no payments under the guarantees. The White House nonetheless listed that guarantee on its Ohio scorecard as a delivered win for the state, as J News Network reported on Nov. 3. And the guarantee does not cover the whole campus: credit support for the remaining roughly 3.8 gigawatts remains an option Nvidia may exercise “in its sole discretion.” It has not exercised it, and the option was not mentioned on Nvidia’s Nov. 17 earnings call.

The numbers in the term sheet itself were presented by Overly, and they are SB Energy’s proposal, not a signed agreement: a data center campus “built in phases with up to 17 data center buildings on several thousand acres” at or around PORTS-Pike; approximately 2,500 jobs at average wages of over $100,000; a 100 percent real property tax abatement for up to 15 years per building; and, in exchange, payments in lieu of taxes that Overly said “could be valued up to $1.5 billion,” beginning with $10 million within five business days of a definitive agreement and including $300 million in milestone payments as the first buildings are financed and come online. Overly also told the room the board had authorized a predevelopment agreement with SB Energy on July 23 of this year.

The project on paper — and in the permit record

The 17-building figure is not a meeting invention; it comes from SB Energy’s own registration statement filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, which describes 17 contracted data-center buildings with approximately 8,024 megawatts of capacity. But the same filing, as J News Network reported on Oct. 27, places only one of those buildings on the land SB Energy leases from the Department of Energy. A substantial majority of the campus is expected to stand on private property — the farmland around the plant, not the federal reservation where the project was announced in March.

Map of the PORTS-Pike site area in Pike County, Ohio

The permit record is further behind than the presentation. On Oct. 29 and Oct. 30, Ohio EPA ruled the water permit applications for both the six-building Bobo Road data center project and the Artemis gas-fired power plant incomplete, and told SB Energy’s companies the state “will not proceed with any further review” until the missing material is filed. Neither project has the state water certification it needs, and Ohio EPA’s review of the Artemis application has not begun on the merits. The campus capacity Nvidia described on Nov. 17 comes online in phases beginning in calendar 2028, and under the framework announced March 20, 2026, by DOE, SB Energy and AEP Ohio, power is expected to begin flowing to the site in 2029.

The jobs figure — approximately 2,500 jobs at average wages over $100,000 — is a projection in the proposal Overly presented, carried in a non-binding document; no jobs commitment has been signed. SB Energy’s own SEC filing categorizes the PORTS-Pike capacity as contracted but not yet under construction.

The foundation: 20 percent of money that does not exist yet

The one commitment the commissioners claimed as their own — not the company’s — concerned the Pike 2040 foundation the agreement would create.

“As commissioners, of the first $300 million that John [laid out], we made a commitment that 20 percent of that will go into the foundation,” one commissioner said. “The beauty of that is that that won’t be decided by us three commissioners or future commissioners. It’s going to be decided by citizens of Pike County that are nominated and put on that board, to decide on what projects and what charitable donations to make.”

“We’re going to do our best to put in an intergovernmental agreement to bind that the best we can for the future,” he continued. “When the next generation of commissioners come along, they would have to stick to that in some way. You can only do so much to tie the hands of future elected officials. But we really want this foundation. This foundation, in my opinion, can be the most important part of this entire agreement… That’s the thing that we can use to touch every single citizen of Pike County — not just touch them, but benefit them.”

Watch: a commissioner commits 20 percent of the first $300 million to the Pike 2040 foundation, to be decided by citizens of Pike County, not the commissioners. (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)
The commissioners at the table, with a resident's copy of the term sheet in the foreground

The record: Twenty percent of the first $300 million is $60 million — payable only if the milestone payments are ever made, which requires a definitive agreement that does not exist and buildings that have not been financed, permitted or built. And the commissioner’s own words concede the commitment’s limit: “You can only do so much to tie the hands of future elected officials.” The foundation is a promise inside a non-binding document, funded by projections, that its own authors acknowledge they cannot fully bind.

The same commissioner said the agreement’s workforce language was written locally: “Jennifer and some of the locals wrote the wording to go in the agreement. And the attorneys — SB Energy’s attorneys — they didn’t touch that wording at all. It is totally by Pike County folks… forming a pathway for every single student in Pike County… If you want to stay here, and we want you to stay here, then we’re willing to help — we’re willing to fund a pathway for you to stay. Nobody wants to leave their home.”

Watch: the workforce-pathway wording was written by Pike County locals, a commissioner says — “SB Energy’s attorneys — they didn’t touch that wording at all.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

The timeline: the board’s stated reason is the $10 million

Asked when a definitive agreement might be signed, a commissioner gave the board’s only timeline of the day — and its reason for moving quickly.

“Right now we don’t have a timeline. We would definitely like to get it signed here in the next week or so, two weeks, something like that,” he said. “And one of the biggest reasons is this $10 million upfront PILOT that John had mentioned. That’s going to go to the taxing districts that are in the PILOT. Some of those districts are in dire need of funds. So we want to do this right, but we also want to get funds to the places in Pike County that need it desperately. We don’t have a date — we’re not going to sign this on the 25th, we don’t have that. We want public input. But we also want to help them financially as soon as we can.”

Watch: a commissioner gives the board’s timeline — a definitive agreement “in the next week or so, two weeks” — and its reason, the $10 million upfront PILOT. (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

The record: The $10 million does not arrive under the document the board approved. By Overly’s own statement at the same meeting, it comes only within five business days of a definitive agreement — and no definitive agreement has been signed. The board’s stated reason for signing within “a week or so, two weeks” is money that exists only on the other side of that signature.

The PILOT money, another commissioner explained, “will be received into the county just like taxes. They’ll come into the Treasurer’s Office, and the Auditor’s Office will disperse those to the taxing districts, just the same as if they were taxes” — the same percentages to the school districts, the career center, EMS and the townships as tax dollars would carry. What that explanation does not mention is the other side of the trade presented in the same term sheet: a 100 percent real property tax abatement for up to 15 years per building. The districts would receive the percentages of a payment negotiated in place of taxes — on a campus whose buildings pay no real property tax at all for up to a decade and a half each.

Watch: a commissioner explains how the PILOT money will be received into the county and dispersed by the Auditor’s Office to the taxing districts. (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

The cancer question — and the record the commissioner confirmed

The longest exchange of the meeting was not about the data center. A resident who said she has campaigned for seven years on the county’s cancer rate told the board she had “not heard one time anybody say anything about the cancer rate here in this county,” citing an infant child cancer rate she said is 50 percent above the national average, a member of her group who died with 19 tumors, and four Pike County ZIP codes included in a federal Radiation Exposure Compensation Act bill. “We want to hear it in real time,” she said. “We want transparency. We want accountability, and it’s time. It’s high time.”

A commissioner answered at length, and did not dispute her premise.

“It’s been an uphill battle for the last 70 years. There’s no question there. And the fight is still going on,” he said. “…This community didn’t choose [the plant]. They chose this community. And we have, as a community, through the Council of Governments, which now represents almost every political subdivision in the county, we’ve been pushing the Department of Energy for answers. We were able to [commission] testing — sampling within six miles of the plant. That has demonstrated, you’re right, some residential properties that have levels that exceed what EPA says is safe. That is unacceptable. We believe that that is a DOE-related responsibility. These are their isotopes.”

Watch: a commissioner answers the cancer question, confirming that sampling within six miles of the plant found residential properties with levels that exceed what EPA says is safe: “These are their isotopes.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)
The three commissioners at the table during the cancer exchange

The record: What the commissioner described is not new information — it is the documented history of this site, and it is worse than the meeting version. In a sitewide environmental covenant recorded with the Pike County Recorder on Aug. 18, 2026, DOE moved to post warning signs at 112 locations along the creeks draining the plant — the first time in the plant’s history the federal government physically marked those waters off-limits — because, under a 2023 Ohio EPA decision, the creek sediment exceeds recreational exposure limits for hazardous substances, as J News Network reported in August. DOE’s own PEGASIS monitoring system has recorded uranium isotopes at multiples of detection limits in surface water and sediment near Valley High School, Valley Local Middle School and the Waverly City Schools, and in 2019 Zahn’s Corner Middle School was closed after enriched uranium was discovered inside the school, as J News Network reported on Nov. 10. That is the ground on which the board is now siting the project its backers call the largest data center project in the country.

He said many of the tested residential properties that exceeded acceptable thresholds “have actually been acquired by [SB Energy]. Not all of them. Not the one that tested highest… But many of those have been [acquired],” and that converting the land from residential to industrial use is “contributing to the solution” — while conceding, “obviously more has to be done. Don’t think that this is the solution… This is a complicated puzzle. We are working earnestly in trying to figure out a way to resolve it.”

The record: The acquisitions the commissioner described as part of the solution are part of a much larger land assembly around the site. SB Energy’s land company, Portsmouth Landco, paid $86,738,170 for 781 acres around the site in two closings — about $111,000 an acre, more than eleven times the county auditor’s market values for the same parcels, as J News Network reported on Oct. 26. One parcel had changed hands eight months earlier for $5,148,500 and sold to Landco for $22,900,000. And by the commissioner’s own statement, the property that tested highest has not been acquired at all. It is still residential.

When the resident proposed spending some of the project’s money on a cancer health center so patients would not have to travel for treatment, a second commissioner left the door open: “In Pike County, this is an extremely important subject… We’ve got some plans, short term, long term. There are a lot of options. So I’m not going to rule out anything, other than we’re going to do our absolute best, and even ask for some help with maybe some municipal planners. One thing we’re positive of is that we don’t know everything.” No cancer center was among the terms presented at the meeting. The resident’s proposal was not ruled out. It was not adopted or funded either.

Watch: asked about the proposed cancer health center, a commissioner leaves the door open — “I’m not going to rule out anything… One thing we’re positive of is that we don’t know everything.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

What they said they can’t control

Residents pressed the board on matters the commissioners said sit outside their authority: AEP transmission lines residents say are planned across farms and within feet of homes, with surveyors entering property uninvited and eminent domain invoked; landlords holding houses for construction workers at rents residents put at $2,000 to $3,000 a month; and traffic on U.S. 23 that a resident said already backs up an hour or more.

The record: The transmission lines are not a rumor. AEP’s Baku-Gavin line — roughly 51 miles of 765-kilovolt line from the proposed Baku Substation near Piketon to the Gavin Substation, crossing Pike, Jackson and Gallia counties — is a filed case before the Ohio Power Siting Board (Case No. 26-0426), built to feed this campus, and was the subject of a public hearing in Jackson on Oct. 27, as J News Network reported on Oct. 16. A second AEP line for the planned PORTS Technology Campus has not reached the application stage at all: as J News Network reported on Nov. 13, AEP has filed only a pre-application notification letter in Case No. 26-1060-EL-BTX.

On the power lines, a commissioner promised to intervene where the county can: “We need to approach AEP and say, hey, if you’re doing something out of line, then you’ve got to change. SB Energy needs approached to say, hey, this deals with your data center, this is your power coming in — you need to do something about it.” Overly added that the commissioners “only have so much authority — they are creatures of statute,” and asked residents to bring complaints about unauthorized entry to the county so it can take them to AEP.

On traffic, a commissioner said the county engineer “has been working with ODOT to try to figure out the traffic situation we know is coming. It’s here. It’s already here. We expect it to get worse,” and that SB Energy, not taxpayers, will pay the road costs — “that’s been [the position] from the very beginning, and they haven’t denied that it’s their responsibility.”

Asked what would happen to the cemeteries inside the project area, a commissioner answered plainly: “We haven’t really talked about cemeteries… I don’t have an answer for that. And [we’re told] it’s okay to say I don’t know. So I don’t know, but we can get back to you.”

Watch: asked what will happen to the cemeteries inside the project area, a commissioner answers: “I don’t know, but we can get back to you.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

“You’re going up against a Goliath”

The meeting’s most striking passage came when a commissioner took up the power plants that are not part of this agreement — and the federal government he expects to own them.

“There’s no secret here — the federal government is going to take over the power plant. That’s just what’s going to happen,” he said. “Bottom line is, when they do that, it will be subject to a payment in lieu of taxes. That will have to be negotiated. Do I like it? Not necessarily. [We’ve] dealt with [it] for 75 years down there… Our team is prepared to negotiate when that time comes, but there’s no guarantee. I don’t want to tell you something that’s not true… When you go up against the federal government, you’re going up against a Goliath. But remember, David took down Goliath with one stone.”

“We didn’t choose — they chose us, 75 years ago,” he said. “This is different. This is different. We’re dealing with private industry here. We’re trying to take care of you folks. We really are trying to take care of you the best we can.”

Watch: “When you go up against the federal government, you’re going up against a Goliath. But remember, David took down Goliath with one stone.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)
The commissioners at the table during the Goliath passage

The record: The power plants are the part of this project with no agreement, no abatement terms and — as of Oct. 30 — an incomplete permit application. Overly told the room the power generation facility is not part of the term sheet and would not receive the tax abatement, and a commissioner said there is no agreement on the power plants yet: “That will have to be worked out with the federal government… We’ll definitely keep everybody informed.” The gas plant in the permit record — the Artemis facility, proposed at up to 1.77 gigawatts — is one of the two SB Energy projects Ohio EPA stopped reviewing in October for incomplete applications. Meanwhile, the cleanup that is supposed to make room for this future is nowhere near finished: the X-326 process building is fully demolished and its slab is being graded for the planned campus, but demolition of X-333, the next building, stood at about 9 percent as of Nov. 12, by DOE’s own number — and the demolition debris is being buried on the site itself, in the on-site disposal facility residents fought for years before DOE built it anyway.

The vote

Late in the meeting, a resident asked the question the day had been building toward: “Is this planned on being voted on today so it can go through?” A commissioner confirmed it was the plan, and when the resident asked whether the vote could be postponed so the issues raised could be looked at, Overly read from the resolution itself — that approving the term sheet and making it public “will promote transparency, allow residents and affected political subdivisions to review it” and build toward negotiations, “and that they’re requesting public input.”

Watch: a resident asks whether the term sheet is planned to be voted on today; a commissioner confirms it is — “that’s our plan.” (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

“I would recommend to the board today that they approve it, because what it does, it starts the process,” Overly said. “They’re not bound to it… We want a baseline. We want comments.” Asked whether distributing money under a passed term sheet would make it binding, Overly answered: “There won’t be any money until we sign the definitive agreement. And that won’t be today.”

The board then voted. A motion was made and seconded, and the presiding commissioner announced an affirmative vote. The resolution approving the term sheet carried. Overly also told the room the county held an ethics training for all county officials the previous Friday with the Ohio Ethics Commission — a step he said his firm recommended over the summer — and that the commission’s opinions and a video of the training are part of the public record.

Watch: the vote itself — the motion, the second, and the presiding commissioner’s announcement of an affirmative vote on the term-sheet resolution. (Recording: Pam Cutler Ison)

The county’s PORTS-Pike project page states that no final agreement with SB Energy has been signed. The board’s next meetings, per the county’s release, are Thursday, Nov. 19, and Monday, Nov. 23, at 9 a.m. at the Government Center in Waverly. What the board approved on Nov. 18 was a baseline, in its own lawyer’s word — a non-binding term sheet, finalized at 1:30 in the morning, presented to the full board for the first time at the meeting that approved it, resting on figures its own county release states differently, for a project whose permits Ohio EPA stopped reviewing three weeks earlier, on ground where the federal government has now posted the creeks off-limits over contaminated sediment. The definitive agreement — the one with the money in it — remains unsigned, and its terms are not public.

Reporting note: This story is built from the complete recording of the Nov. 18, 2026, special meeting, recorded by Pike County resident Pam Cutler Ison and posted publicly on her Facebook page. Every quotation was transcribed from that recording and verified against the audio. Figures attributed to the term sheet are the presenters’ and commissioners’ claims as stated at the meeting; the term sheet text itself was not published with the county’s release, and J News Network has not independently verified the projected figures. Where this story tests those claims, it does so against the public record — SB Energy’s SEC filings, Ohio EPA rulings, Nvidia’s SEC filings and earnings call, DOE records, and Ohio Power Siting Board cases — as reported in J News Network’s previous coverage, linked in the text. This story is part of The Fallout Files, J News Network’s continuing coverage of the PORTS-Pike site.

Advertisement
Whatnot

One thought on “Finalized at 1:30 a.m., approved the same day: the SB Energy term sheet, tested claim by claim against the record”

Leave a Reply

Verified Website

See Report

AdvertisementShopify