The Fallout Files

Ohio EPA records document petroleum spills, wetland violations and repeat stormwater failures

New Ohio EPA records document petroleum spills near storm sewer inlets, unauthorized wetland construction, repeat stormwater-control violations and drinking-water treatment failures across Ohio.

Advertisement

COLUMBUS, Ohio — A new set of Ohio Environmental Protection Agency records documents oil and fuel spills near storm sewer inlets at a Hardin County scrap-metal operation, unauthorized construction inside a regulated wetland in Summit County, repeated stormwater-control failures at a Coshocton County construction project and drinking-water treatment violations in Pickaway County.

J News Network re-opened the underlying Ohio EPA eDocuments before publication and removed several claims from an earlier scan that could not be confirmed in the source records. The findings below reflect only what the Oct. 20, 2026 documents explicitly establish.

Advertisement
Advertisement
CapCut

Oil, diesel and gasoline spills documented at Whitaker Enterprises

Ohio EPA issued a Notice of Violation to Whitaker Enterprises in Hardin County following an Oct. 8 inspection tied to complaint ID 260915091215_WEC.

The notice documents several petroleum spills at the facility, including motor oil covering about 100 square feet in front of an older maintenance building, a roughly 10-by-20-foot pool of oil near the facility entrance and a larger spill in a vehicle repair and maintenance area measuring about 30 by 40 feet.

Advertisement
Southwest Airlines Rapid Rewards

Inspectors also documented a diesel fuel spill of roughly 5 by 10 feet and a gasoline spill of about 2 by 3 feet. Ohio EPA said storm sewer inlets were not covered or otherwise protected from pollutant discharges.

Advertisement

The agency cited the facility under industrial stormwater requirements associated with NPDES ID 8CU00958 and the state’s multi-sector general permit, OHR000007.

Ohio EPA directed the facility to immediately clean up oil and hazardous-material spills and protect storm sewer inlets and vehicle-repair areas. The notice does not identify a 30-day compliance deadline, does not mention batteries or an uncovered diesel tank and does not state that the facility is adjacent to Taylor Creek or the Scioto River.

Primary source: Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293592.

Hidden Lakes cited over wetland construction and dam condition

Ohio EPA issued two separate Oct. 20 notices involving TWL Hidden Lakes LLC in Summit County.

One notice says construction occurred within a regulated federal wetland area without a permit or applicable exception. The work described by the agency included a roughly 1,000-foot-long, 42-inch-diameter sanitary sewer pipeline and a permanent building addition within the wetland area.

Ohio EPA cited Ohio Revised Code Section 6111.04 and Ohio Administrative Code Rule 3745-1-04. The agency directed the company to cease unauthorized activity in the regulated wetland area and submit a detailed corrective-action plan within 30 days.

A second notice involving Hidden Lakes Dam states that the dam was not maintained in good repair and condition following a Sept. 15 inspection by the Summit Soil and Water Conservation District.

The records reviewed do not support an earlier description of a dam breach that sent sediment 1 to 1.5 miles downstream. Neither of the two Oct. 20 source documents reviewed for this report contains that claim.

Primary sources: Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293591 and Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293526.

Bigfoot Lake cited again after earlier 2023 and 2025 notices

Ohio EPA issued another Notice of Violation to Bigfoot Lake LLC following an Oct. 14 inspection of the company’s construction project in Coshocton County.

The Oct. 20 notice cites multiple stormwater-control deficiencies under permit 0GC04093, including an inaccessible and outdated Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan, missing or incomplete weekly inspection records, deficient silt fencing and construction waste that was not properly managed or contained.

The agency said some silt fencing had gaps or tears that allowed sediment to escape.

The notice expressly references earlier enforcement letters dated Jan. 23, 2023, and Aug. 7, 2025.

Ohio EPA ordered immediate corrective action, including updating the pollution-prevention plan, beginning and documenting weekly inspections, installing and maintaining proper perimeter silt fencing and properly managing construction waste. The Oct. 20 notice does not give the company a 14-day deadline.

Primary source: Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293220.

Pickaway County water systems receive separate notices

Ohio EPA also issued Oct. 20 drinking-water Notices of Violation to Carvel Manor Mobile Home Park and the Village of Ashville.

At Carvel Manor, PWS ID OH6500312, the agency said the distribution system failed to maintain the required chlorine residual on six days during September 2026. State rules cited in the notice require at least 0.2 milligrams per liter of free chlorine or 1.0 milligram per liter of combined chlorine at representative points in the distribution system.

The document does not provide specific chlorine measurements for those six days and does not establish that customers became ill.

In Ashville, PWS ID OH6500012, Ohio EPA cited the village for failing to maintain iron-removal equipment so it functioned as intended. The notice references the state’s secondary maximum contaminant level for iron of 0.3 milligrams per liter and directs the village to review its operations and advise the agency within 30 days what corrections will be made.

The Ashville notice specifically states that public notification is not required. The source document reviewed for this story does not identify four specific weeks in September or provide individual iron measurements.

Primary sources: Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293548 — Carvel Manor and Ohio EPA eDocs document 4293547 — Village of Ashville.

What the records establish

The Whitaker notice documents actual petroleum spills and unprotected storm sewer inlets, but the record reviewed for this report does not establish that petroleum reached a named stream or river. The Hidden Lakes records document unauthorized wetland construction and a separate dam-maintenance violation, not the previously described downstream sediment event. The Bigfoot Lake notice documents repeat stormwater-control problems and prior NOVs. The Pickaway County notices document treatment and disinfection compliance failures but do not establish illness or a disease outbreak.

No newly verified TCE, PCE, vinyl chloride, arsenic, PFAS, lead or benzene exceedance was identified in the source documents reviewed for this report.


Ohio EPA documents reviewed:
4293592 — Whitaker Enterprises
4293591 — TWL Hidden Lakes LLC wetlands notice
4293526 — Hidden Lakes Dam notice
4293220 — Bigfoot Lake LLC
4293548 — Carvel Manor MHP
4293547 — Village of Ashville.

Advertisement
Whatnot

Leave a Reply

Verified Website

See Report

AdvertisementShopify