CIRCLEVILLE, Ohio — A man arrested after a September vehicle pursuit in Pickaway County has pleaded guilty to felonious assault and two other felony counts, according to the case record in Pickaway County Common Pleas Court.
James W. Picklesimer, 43, pleaded guilty Nov. 10 to all three counts of his indictment before Judge Matthew H. Chafin: first-degree felony felonious assault, third-degree felony failure to comply with an order or signal of a police officer, and fourth-degree felony receiving stolen property, the docket shows.
The indictment alleges Picklesimer knowingly caused or attempted to cause physical harm to Pickaway County Deputy Josiah Bever, a peace officer, by means of a deadly weapon — a motor vehicle. The failure-to-comply count alleges he willfully fled after an officer signaled him to stop, causing a substantial risk of serious physical harm. The receiving stolen property count involves a red 2013 Toyota Tacoma owned by Celestino Beltran Arreola, according to the indictment.
Under the plea agreement filed with the court, the state will recommend four years in prison on the felonious assault count and 12 months on the failure-to-comply count, served consecutively, with 12 months on the receiving stolen property count served at the same time, plus a two-year Reagan Tokes tail. The plea petition lists his maximum possible exposure as 11 to 16.5 years on the assault count, 36 months on the failure-to-comply count and 18 months on the receiving stolen property count. A presentence investigation was ordered, in part to determine restitution.
Chafin accepted the plea, found Picklesimer guilty and referred him to the Adult Probation Department for the presentence investigation. The judge ordered him held in the Pickaway County Jail without bond until the investigation is complete. Sentencing is set for Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. No sentence has been imposed.
Picklesimer was arrested Sept. 17, 2026, and indicted Oct. 1. He pleaded not guilty at his Oct. 7 arraignment, when bond was set at $25,000 with conditions that included no contact with the vehicle’s owner. He is represented by court-appointed attorney Tomi L. Dorris. The case, State of Ohio v. Picklesimer, case no. 2026CR0160, is being prosecuted by Pickaway County Prosecutor Jayme Hartley Fountain’s office.
The charges stem from the Sept. 17 pursuit. According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol Aviation Unit’s September 2026 report, patrol aircraft assisted the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office and the Circleville Patrol Post with an active vehicle pursuit that day. Ground units deployed multiple sets of stop sticks, and the suspect vehicle kept fleeing on two rims, swerving at marked police cruisers and striking multiple other vehicles, the report said. Aviation helped coordinate a PIT maneuver; the vehicle was disabled in a ditch and the suspect was taken into custody. Picklesimer was booked into the Pickaway County Jail that day on felonious assault, receiving stolen property, failure to comply and probation violations.
This story is based on the Pickaway County Common Pleas Court record in State of Ohio v. Picklesimer, case no. 2026CR0160, and the Ohio State Highway Patrol Aviation Unit’s September 2026 report.

